,Label,Barcelona,Berlin,Bologna,Lisbon,London,Paris,Tallinn
RF-1 -1,Decentralization - supra city,Regional Capital in Federal State,City-State,Regional Capital,National Capital,National Capital,National Capital,National Capital
RF-1 -2,Decentralization - infra city,Weak sub-municipal bodies,Strong sub-municipal bodies (elected),Strong sub-municipal bodies (elected),Strong sub-municipal bodies (elected),Strong sub-municipal bodies (elected),Weak sub-municipal bodies (appointed),Weak sub-municipal bodies (appointed)
RF-1 -3,Decentralization - Metropolitan Authority,yes,no,yes,yes,yes,yes,no
RF-2,Labour regulation,yes but only through advocacy (soft power),yes but the competence is shared with another public authority,yes but only through advocacy (soft power),yes but only through advocacy (soft power),yes but the competence is shared with another public authority,yes but the competence is shared with another public authority,na
RF-3-1,Sectoral - Tourism,yes but the competence is shared with another public authority,"yes, directly ",-,"yes, directly ","yes, directly ","yes, directly ",yes but the competence is shared with both another public authority and a public agency/utility
RF-3-2,Sectoral - Urban Mobility,yes but the competence is shared with both another public authority and a public agency/utility,yes but the competence is shared with another public authority,-,yes but the competence is shared with both another public authority and a public agency/utility,yes but the competence is shared with a public agency/utility,"yes, directly ",yes but the competence is shared with a public agency/utility
RF-4,Taxation,"yes, but limited to touristic tax","yes, including the possibility to issue taxes on value production ","yes, but limited to touristic tax","yes, including the possibility to issue taxes on value production ","yes, including the possibility to issue taxes on value production ","yes, including the possibility to issue taxes on value production ",no
UPS-1-1,Participatory Democracy,"yes, many","yes, many","yes, some case","yes, many","yes, many","yes, many","yes, some case"
UPS-1-2,Co-design/co-creation,"yes, some case","yes, many","yes, some case","yes, but limited","yes, many","yes, some case","yes, many"
UPS-1-3,DSI Civil Society,0.417204,0.590931,na,0.553746,0.609732,0.57882,0.39366
UPS-2-1,e-participation tools,"yes, unique or main channel","yes, several channels","yes, unique or main channel","yes, several channels","yes, several channels","yes, several channels","yes, several channels"
UPS-2-2-1,e-participation platform,in house,mixed,in house,outsourced,-,in house,outsourced
UPS-2-2-2,e-participation platform - Code,FLOSS,mixed,FLOSS,mixed,-,FLOSS,mixed
UPS-2-3-1,Digital interaction with public authorities (last 12 months),58,59,23,41,63,75,80
UPS-2-3-2,Civic or political participation (last 12 months),22,27,19,24,33,14,14
UPS-2-3-3,Social Network use (last 12 months),60,51,48,65,73,49,60
UPS-2-4,DSI Inclusion,0.71423,0.627655,0,0.619213,0.727641,0.603707,0.591646
UTA-1-1-1,Urban Data Platform - Ownership,in house,public-private-partnership,in house,public-private-partnership,in house,in house,na
UTA-1-1-2,Urban Data Platform - Data,data from public authority and related agencies,data from public authority and related agencies,data from public authority and related agencies,data from public authority and related agencies,data from public authority and related agencies,data from public authority and related agencies,data from public authority and related agencies
UTA-1-1-3,Urban Data Platform - Licenses,Attribution,Attribution,Attribution,Attribution,Attribution,Attribution+Share Alike,na
UTA-1-2-1,DPO appointed,yes,yes,yes,yes,yes,yes,yes
UTA-1-2-2,CIO/CDO appointed,yes,yes,yes,yes,yes,yes,yes
UTA-1-3,User- Centricity of Public Services,93.625,90.125,92.25,95.375,90.5,92,95.875
UTA-1-4,Digital Transformation Networks,4,0,1,4,2,1,1
UTA-2-1,DSI Infrastructure,0.741587,0.59898,0,0.533652,0.749376,0.702665,0.324584
UTA-2-2-1,Persons with tertiary education (ISCED) and/or employed in science and technology - 2019,38.3,50.9,29.7,37.3,58,50.2,43.9
UTA-2-2-2,DSI Skills,0.4008,0.478317,0,0.257025,0.929589,0.601967,0.801782
UTA-2-3-1,Internet use (last 3 M),94,93,82,85,96,91,90
UTA-2-3-2,Purchase online,63,78,46,47,90,74,68
UTA-2-3-3,Selling online,16,29,10,12,30,19,18
UTA-2-4,DSI Collaboration,0.803313,0.470434,0,0.448392,0.806994,0.693415,0.16544
UTA-3-1-1,GAWC_Score,41.45959,33.30957,17.80172,41.13127,100,70.39267,25.38488
UTA-3-1-2,GAWC_Ranking,Beta +,Beta +,Sufficiency,Alpha -,Alpha ++,Alpha +,Sufficiency
UTA-3-2-1,Added value from Knowledge intensive sectors (per capita),970.8672,3133.107,1827.525,1471.055,6984.416,13057.01,2048.616
UTA-3-3,DSI Funding,0.046,0.074,0.035,0.059,0.068,0.079,0.057
UTA-4-1,Platforms-Unicorns,0.55585,0.350333,0,0.169375,0.606328,0.523744,0.183507
UTA-4-2,Platforms-Alternative,22,15,24,16,17,17,11